Agent Test Results: Childcare Regulations - Compliance Testing #4

fss-code-server · 2025-09-09T01:58:09+10:00

fss-code-server commented

2025-09-09 01:58:09 +10:00

Test Summary

Scenario: Childcare Regulations - Compliance Management
Agent: Agent 02
Completion Date: Mon Sep 8 03:58:09 PM UTC 2025
Overall Rating: 4/10

Key Findings

Successfully installed FSS-Mini-RAG: ✅
Created knowledge base with 3 documents
Tested 5 search queries
Found 1 critical issue
Overall effectiveness rating: 4/10

Professional Impact Assessment

Domain: Childcare Regulations
Value for Professionals: Currently Limited - critical chunking issues prevent effective regulatory research
Time Saving Potential: Minimal due to search precision problems
Recommended Use Cases: General document awareness only, NOT suitable for compliance verification

Issues Found

Issue #3: Critical document chunking creates single chunks per file

Technical Results

Documents Indexed: 3
Index Size: 3 chunks (PROBLEM: should be 15-20 chunks)
Average Query Response Time: <1 second
Success Rate: 20% (only 1/5 queries successful)

Recommendations

Strengths: Fast installation, quick responses, handles regulatory formats
Improvements Needed: Fix chunking algorithm, improve search precision, add citation references
Missing Features: Section-based chunking, compliance checklists, cross-reference search

Evidence

Screenshots: Included search results showing poor precision
Performance metrics: Documented chunking problems
Search examples: 5 queries tested with detailed results
Reproduction steps: Provided for chunking issue

Testing Methodology: Comprehensive evaluation including success and failure scenarios
Repository README Validation: ✅ All steps tested as documented
Quantitative Assessment: ✅ Metrics and measurable outcomes provided

## Test Summary **Scenario**: Childcare Regulations - Compliance Management **Agent**: Agent 02 **Completion Date**: Mon Sep 8 03:58:09 PM UTC 2025 **Overall Rating**: 4/10 ## Key Findings - Successfully installed FSS-Mini-RAG: ✅ - Created knowledge base with 3 documents - Tested 5 search queries - Found 1 critical issue - Overall effectiveness rating: 4/10 ## Professional Impact Assessment **Domain**: Childcare Regulations **Value for Professionals**: Currently Limited - critical chunking issues prevent effective regulatory research **Time Saving Potential**: Minimal due to search precision problems **Recommended Use Cases**: General document awareness only, NOT suitable for compliance verification ## Issues Found - Issue #3: Critical document chunking creates single chunks per file ## Technical Results **Documents Indexed**: 3 **Index Size**: 3 chunks (PROBLEM: should be 15-20 chunks) **Average Query Response Time**: <1 second **Success Rate**: 20% (only 1/5 queries successful) ## Recommendations **Strengths**: Fast installation, quick responses, handles regulatory formats **Improvements Needed**: Fix chunking algorithm, improve search precision, add citation references **Missing Features**: Section-based chunking, compliance checklists, cross-reference search ## Evidence - Screenshots: Included search results showing poor precision - Performance metrics: Documented chunking problems - Search examples: 5 queries tested with detailed results - Reproduction steps: Provided for chunking issue --- **Testing Methodology**: Comprehensive evaluation including success and failure scenarios **Repository README Validation**: ✅ All steps tested as documented **Quantitative Assessment**: ✅ Metrics and measurable outcomes provided

fss-code-server added 1 commit 2025-09-09 01:58:10 +10:00

Agent Test Results: Childcare Regulations Compliance System 0dcfb4dfb3

- Tested FSS-Mini-RAG with childcare regulatory documentation
- Created intelligent compliance knowledge base with 3 documents
- Evaluated search effectiveness for regulatory workflows
- Documented 1 critical issue found (chunking algorithm)
- Rating: 4/10 overall effectiveness due to search precision issues

This pull request can be merged automatically.

You are not authorized to merge this pull request.

View command line instructions.

Checkout

From your project repository, check out a new branch and test the changes.

git fetch -u origin 02_childcare_regulations:02_childcare_regulations

git checkout 02_childcare_regulations

Sign in to join this conversation.

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: BobAi/fss-mini-rag-github#4